Museum facing closure

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, January 06, 2009
Profile image for This is SouthDevon

This is SouthDevon

BRIXHAM'S heritage museum may be forced to close its doors for good after half a century of bringing the town's history to life.

Torbay Council's new budget includes a proposal to axe the museum's grant aid from September.

That would mean the end of funding for curator Dr Philip Armitage (pictured below) and admin officer Cathy Craig — and could spell the end of the museum altogether.

The council budget cut to save £11,000 is due to be considered by the scrutiny committee on January 14.

Officers warn councillors the museum depends on grants, adding: "The loss of the Torbay Council grant may affect the sustainability of the museum in the future."

Torbay Council has provided grants to the museum since 1989.

Apart from a two-year period from 2000 to 2002, the annual grant has gradually increased, to last year's grant of £22,200.

This year, the council is proposing to give the museum a grant of just £11,000 and then to 'cease grant aid' from September.

Council grants contribute to nearly 50 per cent of the museum's annual running costs. The rest is made up of visitor charges.

Dr Amitage and museum volunteers held an emergency meeting about the budget proposals yesterday.

He said: "I don't think the council understands we do lots of educational activities at the museum, and research including family history inquiries.

"The museum is quite dynamic, it's not just a static display of a series of objects."

Last year, 393 people, including local school children, visited the museum for themed, activity-led visits, and members of the museum also visited local schools.

In 2008, the museum organised an archaeological dig for 50 local youngsters at Berry Head, plus a mini-archaeological dig for another 40 children inside the museum. And students from Brixham College, Churston Ferrers Grammar School and South Devon College received work placements at the museum last year.

Volunteer manager Stephen Bardwell said Brixham Heritage Museum was the first of Torbay's three museums to gain a national Accreditation status from the Museums, Libraries and Archives Commission, but feared this status may be lost if the grant is cut.

He said: "It is the ceasing of the grant which worries us intensely. We can understand cuts, but this year Brixham Museum seems to be targeted as the council has proposed that Torquay Museum continues to receive a full grant.

"If the proposal to cut the 2009-10 grant is implemented we would need to make our part-time curator redundant which means we would not be able to care for our collections and archives, and greatly reduce our services to schools, other professional organisations and the public.

"All of this would lead to the museum having the dubious distinction of being the first museum in the South West to lose, through no fault of its own, the Accreditation status — with a consequent disqualification when applying for grants from fund-awarding bodies.

"If we lose our funding completely from Torbay Council after September 2009, it would ultimately mean the closure of Brixham's museum.

"This loss would surely be contrary to the mayor's vision for the regeneration of Brixham and a loss of an important tourist asset, not to mention depriving local school children of an educational resource.

"Over its 50 years, Brixham's museum has amassed an important collection of artefacts, documents and photographs entrusted to us by the people of Brixham connected with and portraying Brixham's social and industrial past.

"We have complete lists and histories of trawlers and other vessels built and registered in Brixham since the early 1700s.

"We urge the council to acknowledge the affect this proposal would have and to reconsider it."

11
Tweet this article
Report

11 Comments

  • Profile image for This is SouthDevon

    by Anita Sexon, Malawi, Central Africa

    Friday, January 09 2009, 5:28PM

    “SHAME, SHAME and more shame be heaped on the heads of the Torbay councillors. I was a volunteer at Brixham museum for many years. Dr Amitage, the paid staff and volunteers all work incredibly hard and give 100 percent to further the education of the local children. Even to going into the local schools with presentations regarding different topics.
    We should be celebrating the wonderful work of a local museum winning a National Accreditation. What is the matter with you TORBAY COUNCIL. Once the heritage museum has gone, its gone forever. If you cut back on all the Council junkets you spend thousands of pounds on, and planted that money where it will do some good, you will reap informed children and happier visitors.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthDevon

    by museum manager, brixham

    Wednesday, January 07 2009, 8:06PM

    “if you would like to have a personal tour of the museum
    and find out more about what we do every day, the amount of hard work, dedication and comittment by the staff and volunteers that go's into running this unique heritage museum. please contact me at the museum on 01803 856267

    please help save your heritage

    Steve Bardwell”

  • Profile image for This is SouthDevon

    by carole, brixham

    Wednesday, January 07 2009, 4:14PM

    “the museum must not be closed for the want of a paltry 11,000 .its important for brixham to remember its history especially for the children to learn what life used to be like .please keep the museum open .”

  • Profile image for This is SouthDevon

    by Philip Godden, Brixham

    Wednesday, January 07 2009, 12:15AM

    “"Officers warn councillors the museum depends on grants..."

    Perhaps all council officers should be reminded that payment of their salaries depends upon good performance and achieving results. Surely there can be a cost saving elsewhere within the staffing budget to fund the museum experts?
    I should hope that this ridiculous proposal is not supported by any of the Brixham elected councillors.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthDevon

    by Lucy, Torquay

    Tuesday, January 06 2009, 4:32PM

    “To be fair, if the museum portrays Brixham life, then it's 21 Century section will be full of information and pictures about drugs, druggies, drug life and other drug related thing. Time has changed and brought changes to Brixham with it. This museum has lasted it's use. If the museum continues it will only show the depths to which Brixham sunk to, so for the sake of the Brixham people we are all better off without it.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthDevon

    by Mike Westwood, Brixham

    Tuesday, January 06 2009, 3:31PM

    “Sack Bye Bye and we have the money six times over, and does not include the cost of the damage he does.
    Just think "balloon"”

  • Profile image for This is SouthDevon

    by W Ward, Poole, Dorset

    Tuesday, January 06 2009, 3:07PM

    “I see no reason at all why the council could not fund the paltry £11,000 from the Uninsured Loss Reserve Fund - After all they quietly took £560,000 from the reserve to prop up the losses of the NCP fiasco.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthDevon

    by Bob, Brixham

    Tuesday, January 06 2009, 12:47PM

    “Provide funding for Brixham Museum from pay cuts by the Mayor and his cronies - incomparably better value for money.”

  • Profile image for This is SouthDevon

    by Doc, Torre

    Tuesday, January 06 2009, 12:13PM

    “£11,000 is a small amount to pay to maintain the culture and history of a community. We should be cerebrating the distinctive parts of Torbay, and not surrendering to the idea that all towns should be clones of each other. Museums and local history projects are ways of celebrating the richness of our society, and of maintaining a few islands of distinctiveness in the rising tide of the monopolies of national chains.

    Museums preserve the old and inform us of battles lost and won. The William statue is just a nice piece of carved stone, if no one knows that it is hard evidence of one of the most significant social and political changes in world history. They also exploit new opportunities: Now the Bay has Geopark status, how are we letting residents and visitors know about our unique geology if we close down our museums?”

  • Profile image for This is SouthDevon

    by Jim, The Bay

    Tuesday, January 06 2009, 12:07PM

    “Congratulations to everyone who voted for tax cuts under the Tories back in 1979. Labour have carried on with those policies and this is the result.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters