Torbay councillor "sacked" from children's champion role 'for speaking out'

Trusted article source icon
Monday, June 28, 2010
Profile image for This is Devon

This is Devon

A TORBAY councillor says she has been "sacked" from her role as a children's champion after she spoke out about failings in the children's services department.

Lib Dem Ellacombe ward councillor Cindy Stocks says she was stripped of her role after she made comments in a statement sent to the local media saying the council had been "found wanting".

Torbay Mayor Nick Bye said he was "disappointed" Councillor Stocks had used the matter as an opportunity for what he said was party politics.

He claimed she did not understand the issues raised by Ofsted inspectors, who recently criticised the contact referral and assessment arrangements for some vulnerable children and said the council was not "adequately safeguarding children".

Ms Stocks said she was "devastated" and she had been made a "fall guy".

In the original press release on the matter, issued by Torbay Council's Lib Dem group, Ms Stocks had said: "The key priority for the local authority should be that our children in need are looked after and safe. This report has found the council wanting. I feared this would happen, and have raised concerns with the council about this on numerous occasions, but my concerns do not appear to have been prioritised."

She said she was called in to see the mayor last Thursday afternoon.

She claimed: "When I went in to see him, he was on about this quote which wasn't even published in the Herald Express.

"I said to him I have spoken about my concerns in overview and scrutiny meetings, Cabinet and full council and he said that I hadn't come to him about them.

"I have spoken to the Cabinet member for children's services Councillor Anna Tolchard. I think I am basically being sacked after speaking out on behalf of the children."

Ms Stocks claimed the move was because she was not a "yes man" and had dared to speak out.

"He is trying to use me as a fall guy and trying to put the blame on someone else rather than on his administration," she claimed.

Ms Stocks claimed officers from all levels had raised concerns with her for the past two years about the "pressure they were under" and that the "capacity" wasn't there to safeguard children "effectively".

Mr Bye announced at a full council meeting on Thursday that he had chosen Councillor Julien Parrott to take on Ms Stocks' role and asked Ms Stocks to be champion for staying healthy because of her teenage conception work.

"There are important points to make about the Ofsted report," said Mr Bye.

"The first is we should work together and not see it as a reason for party political points scoring.

"I am very disappointed Cindy was part of the press release sent out by the Lib Dems and saw it as an opportunity for party politics, which is so unhelpful in this area.

"I think the world of Cindy. I paid tribute to her and her work at the full council meeting on Thursday evening but it's absolutely clear and unambiguous what the areas of improvement are in that particular area of children's services.

"Unfortunately, in conversation with Cindy and then when you read through the Lib Dem press release, I don't believe they understand the issues that were raised about professional practice in the report."

Speaking at the meeting at Oldway Mansion, Mayor Bye said it was "unfortunate" it had become a matter for 'personal comment'.

He reiterated the unitary authority was fortunate to have Dr Carol Tozer and Cabinet member for children's services Anna Tolchard to work with the service's team.

Speaking after the meeting, Mr Bye thanked Ms Stocks for "all that she had done", adding: "Councillor Parrott is very good at challenging, and working in a team to improve performance and to make sure that we have the right service to protect the most vulnerable in the Bay."

Mr Parrott pledged to continue to speak out. He said: "This particular issue is quite straightforward. We need to improve our performance, and we will."

But leader of the Lib Dem group, Councillor Steve Darling, said: "Rather than dealing with the problems that Ofsted have identified in their inspection, the mayor seems more interested in carrying out a political vendetta which he hopes will distract the public from his failings."

Ms Tolchard said: "Basically over the last few years, Councillor Stocks and her party have raised questions about funding of children's services so I don't think it's untrue to say that she on occasion has raised concerns.

She added: "I don't think it is because she has spoken out.

"Councillor Stocks had a wide remit chairing the teenage pregnancy board and the corporate parent forum. She has done a good job and is passionate about young people and children but he clearly felt she had a lot on her plate."

34
Tweet this article
Report

34 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Willie, Torbay

    Thursday, July 01 2010, 12:00AM

    “One word says it all about you Ms Pentney, and I dare not write that on here”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Ruth Pentney, Paignton

    Wednesday, June 30 2010, 10:28PM

    “Voter, you have no understanding at all about local government. I never said I was hard done by. Where does all this nonsense come from? You ask a question and then go into a rant when you get a answer. You are voter, well so am I and I give my name. Council tax payer well so am I and I give my name. An income tax payer I am, but are you? Don't be a coward, surely an upright person like yourself has no need to hide his name?”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Voter, Torquay

    Wednesday, June 30 2010, 7:06PM

    “Thank you, again, for your reply, Cllr Pentney.

    The simple fact remains that only councillors qualify to be childrens champions, in the sense that Cllr Stocks is/was one. Ergo, it is work of a councillor. Therefore, OUR taxes are paying for it.

    If you were not willing to do this work when you stood to be a councillor, then you shouldn't stand for election in the first place.

    What next, demanding overtime for all those endless, boring (and useless for the most part, it seems) committee meetings?

    There is a thriving and well-populated voluntary sector in the Bay (and, heaven knows, it needs it). You don't hear them - those at the Samaritans or the CAB, for example - bleating on about it being "extra" work.

    If you're so hard done by, I suggest you stand down next May.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Ruth Pentney, Paignton

    Wednesday, June 30 2010, 6:40PM

    “All champions take on extra work for which they don't get paid. If they were only interested in the money they won't take up these posts.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Voter, Torquay

    Wednesday, June 30 2010, 6:12PM

    “Thank you, Cllr Pentney, for that unasked for list of the splendid works you do on our behalf. Gosh, don't you work hard. It would have been more interesting if you told us exactly how effective you personally have been at each of the meetings you have attended. Without that information, a list of committees, no matter how exhaustive, is completely meaningless. Or are they mostly just talking shops?

    You stated in an earlier post (28 June at 1.19pm) that Cllr Stocks and the other childrens champions do not get paid for these posts. Yes, they do. A minimum of £8k per year out of OUR pockets. Plus expenses for those who claim them.

    You do Cllr Stocks no favours at all with your brand of defence of her position. Perhaps the Lib Dems should find someone else to undertake their PR on this site.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Ann, Preston

    Tuesday, June 29 2010, 9:31PM

    “My, some people sound bitter....... I am appalled at the sacking of Cindy Stocks.... as one who is aware of the dirty tatics in politics I would say Cindy Stocks has been made the scapegoat.... The 2 that should have gone are Tolchard and Tozer, they are clearly NOT DOING the job they are paid to do .as for Bye and Raikes they you hang your heads in shame...... I would say to Karen, just sit on the adoption panel as I did ..think you may be surprised !!!!!”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Ruth Pentney, Paignton

    Tuesday, June 29 2010, 9:15PM

    “So person asked what 'perks' I get? None that I am aware of!”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Karen, Torquay

    Tuesday, June 29 2010, 4:18PM

    “Sorry, I meant bleated...”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by Karen Jemmett, Torquay

    Tuesday, June 29 2010, 4:16PM

    “It's the old maxim - points means prizes, isnt it?

    When you consider that joining the ranks of the 'vulnerable' in society gives some desperate people the basic means to feed and house themselves, it's not surprising that the care system thrives and so many people have a vested interest in defending it.

    But what kind of quality of life do you really think these children have? Many have to contend with the collaboration of their own relatives who may gain a financial advantage from any dyfunctional or dysmorphic label attached to them at a young age.

    But most just suffer from life-long low self-esteem, which is institutionally reinforced by policies of subordinated inclusion. This is why so many people raised in care go on to embrace a counter-cultural existence involving drug-related crime, if only as a rejection of a mainstream society that defines them as problematic or inferior.

    Martin Amis's novel The Pregnant Widow offers a useful critique of alleged neuroses and phantom handicaps which he says are just excuses for mothers and fathers to dope their children. He goes on to say that, in America, which was the future, 60% of household pets were on mood drugs.

    The trouble is that in Torbay, it's been fashionably philanthropic for Liberals to bleet about Children's Services in much the same way Labour bleeted about "poor NHS nurses" when they were woefully under-paid by the Conservatives. But emotive rhetoric can throw up subjective symbols that endure in people's minds indefinitely and blind them to the reality of the present.

    What's needed now is a revolution in care in the UK. And the only way to achieve that is to stop the age-old Victorian Liberal tradition Cindy unwittingly represents. That means resisting the temptation to use scientific labelling to stigmatise people who are simply poor or unwaged.”

  • Profile image for This is Devon

    by OS, Off Meadfoot Beach.

    Tuesday, June 29 2010, 4:14PM

    “Ruth Pentney,

    Do you ever read what has been written, I told you the wages, and you are a councillor, no wonder the place is in a mess.

    Glad you told what you do in your address, it was not asked for, what are the hidden perks you get, we all know you do. You get £11,988.78 in above the board payments, what do you get under the table. Why are you an ex-director of the late Riviera Housing? And how do you fit in the time to write on here if you you are a 24/7 councillor. Guess you have your broadband paid for by us mugs that pay you through our council taxes.

    I do more work for two charities than you will ever do and I do not get paid for it, one is the British Heart Foundation and the other is Help for Heroes.

    Yes I am the father of Rex, who lost his arm in Afghanistan, yes he is the guy you tried to bully on here and even tried to report to his seniors through your mate Sanders, did not work did it Ruth Pentney. Rex is alive and well and now works in Torquay.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters